Why are women and transgender folk
allowed to wear bottoms?
Here at Naked in Motion, we do things a little differently. This isn't your average nudist club.
The Naked in Motion nudity rule states:
Naked! = Nudity is mandatory, but women and trans folk have the option to wear bottoms for any reason. Please note that having your menstrual cycle doesn’t necessitate wearing bottoms, as we don’t want menstruation to limit your attendance. For transgender participants: please make use of anything you require to affirm and support your gender, as we’ll defer to whatever “Naked!” means to you.
The short answer:
It’s a complex issue, but our very specific rule is part of what makes Naked in Motion more than just a nudist attraction; it’s a social movement aligned with the values of feminism, inclusivity, and equity designed to reach people outside the nudist bubble. After centuries of objectification, oppression, and sexual abuse, women and trans folk generally have more to fear when entering a co-ed Naked! space. There is nothing truly equal about the experience of a man and a woman naked in a room together, so this rule is about equity, not equality, and we aim to provide marginalized or disadvantaged groups the tools they need for success. To show those participants that we understand their perspective, we allow them the option to wear bottoms if it makes them feel safer, affirms their gender, or makes menstrual management more comfortable for the purpose of our classes. (A note on menses: having your period doesn’t necessitate wearing bottoms. A cup or tampon works well enough for some folks, but some others need an extra layer of protection. Some people can’t use insertable cups or tampons, making bottoms necessary to hold a pad in place.)
The long answer:
Women have faced centuries of oppression, sexual objectification, and violence, so it's easy to understand why they might be generally more apprehensive about attending an all-gender naked event. Additionally, we understand that some transgender participants (people whose gender identity does not correspond with their birth sex) may not feel comfortable exposing their genitals or may wish to wear bottoms to help affirm their gender. Cisgender men (men whose gender identity corresponds with their sex assigned at birth) certainly have insecurities about their bodies, and we absolutely understand the vulnerability that comes with disrobing. But this isn't about body insecurity, because all people struggle with the way they feel about how their body looks or functions. It's about women's and trans people’s perceived ideas of their safety in a nude space, fears that are often disproportionately higher than those of cis men.
It's also not about equality, or making a space where everyone has to follow the same rule; it's about equity, which levels the playing field for a greater chance of success among disadvantaged groups. Men and women generally have different experiences and concerns when attending a co-ed naked yoga class, and we have gathered this knowledge from the feedback of women who have attended class and those who still don’t feel confident enough to participate. Additionally, we don’t feel the need to mimic other nudist events and require everyone to shed their bottoms. Those spaces exist aplenty. We’re offering something slightly different, and it’s perfectly acceptable to create new and unique spaces in the world!
Naked in Motion classes are designed to be naked (as described in the name), so if we allowed everyone to wear bottoms, it wouldn't necessarily be a Naked! space. A topless man wearing shorts is not really naked, and it's a sight one would easily see running down the street or at a gym. When women shed their tops, they're already participating in nudity, and forcing them to ditch their bottoms is double the work in a potentially more uncomfortable environment. To us, a topless woman is “naked.” Additionally, we’re not just trying to reach the Naked! bubble. We want to attract female and transgendered students who never thought they'd ever participate in a social nude event, and we believe this rule helps to encourage those new folks to attend.
The results of this rule have been that significantly more women and trans folk attend Naked in Motion classes. This hasn’t actually resulted in many more people wearing bottoms, as that’s still a relatively uncommon occurrence. When someone does wear bottoms in class, it’s barely noticeable, and we’re just thrilled that they’re there. It's truly the dream for Naked in Motion to create spaces where all people can experience the freedom and empowerment of clothes-free movement without worrying about their safety. However, until all people feel comfortable completely disrobing, we’re happy to support the journeys of the women and trans folk who feel the need to wear bottoms, and we expect all the students to respect their needs.
We’re blazing a new trail in the world of fitness, yoga, and nudism, and we're challenging the very definition of nudity in favor of equity, looking towards a future where all people can comfortably experience the liberation and empowerment of Naked! movement. We understand the concerns you may have and always welcome your feedback. However, we really appreciate your cooperation and support as we tread new waters.